16 Comments
Nov 2, 2020Liked by Stuart McDonald

My husband and I (in our sixties) spent 2.5 weeks traveling through Java , with additional days in Borneo and an added week in Flores, for a month all together. My husband is dutch, so he has always wanted to visit Indonesia. We have been to Bali, but that is a whole different experience. What surprised us most about Java, was the open friendliness of the people, and a totally different version of Islam than the one we hear about in the news. And we loved that the women are not shy, and generally self assured and open. The nature and landscapes are amazing, and being out of season (February/March) as well, we felt like we were the only foreigners around, and never felt awkward for that. Bromo is fantastic, but we also loved discovering the other cities and the food. Was also interesting to see the architecture and remnants the dutch left behind.

We always felt safe . We traveled by private car, so had that advantage. A trip I would highly recommend!!

Expand full comment
author

Hi Helaine, yes agree totally—a beautiful place and the people are amazing.

Expand full comment
Nov 2, 2020Liked by Stuart McDonald

I've been to Java in 2017 forty years after my first visit to the island. I arrived with my daughter from Flores and Manado where we dived quite a lot. Getting into the moslem-driven town of Yogjakarta changed a bit our surrounding (early prayers a.s.o.) but as we got out of the tourist paths we enjoyed marvellous encounters with the people. Eating and chatting about their world.... My daughter then travelled to Bali despite my negative recommendations ( I had been to Bali quite a lot in the 70ies and it was wonderful and quiet then ) and confirmed my reservations. I went into Jakarta... and a stunning adventure began: Meeting a student friend of the 60ies, he and his family gave me stunning insides into the multilayer world Stuart has mentioned in his long read. He being a christian, his wife a moslem, his daughter an atheistic hotel entrepreneur, his two sons both teachers in public schools in Bandung and Jakarta: what a mix of a family! I spent a whole week with them and wondered how Western individualism has left us with isolation and lonelyness, in case... Go and discover Java!

Expand full comment
author

Hi Klaus, sounds like you had a great trip—and I agree—go and discover Java!

Expand full comment
Nov 1, 2020Liked by Stuart McDonald

I get why it doesn't get the attention it deserves of travellers. It's big and the sections east, central and Jakarta and surrounds don't appear distinct initially and when planning a trip understanding how to tackle it requires a lot of research. How much time to dedicate to the island, to each place, how long to linger and how fast to move on. I spent hours and hours planning a five-night stay from Bali to Yogya and back. Two nights in Solo, one near Borobudur and two in Yogya. An extra night in each would have been good. Transport was difficult/slow even with a private car and driver. It was a great adventure and I'd return in a heartbeat. Really keen to try their rail system. And I'd love a trip dedicated to finding the amazing Art Deco architecture across the island.

Expand full comment
author

Yeah, it does take a bit more work to get a handle on and like you say, can always do with more time. I really enjoyed Solo in particular. And yes, the architecture is so under-rated.

Expand full comment

Subscribing to Travelfish was a big part of being able to get a handle on how to travel in Java.

Expand full comment
Nov 1, 2020Liked by Stuart McDonald

If you do then please visit Pekalongan, as we have arranged a Back To 50's houses trip... so many colonials residence are still well kept in our small city of Pekalongan, the Batik City

Expand full comment
Nov 1, 2020Liked by Stuart McDonald

Sounds great. Java is almost impossibly big, population-wise, for an Australian to comprehend. Pekalongan wasn't a city I'd ever heard of prior to you mentioning it and if you have a link to your 50s house trip please share it.

Expand full comment

I like the comment about 'a lot of research'. I have travelled Java from one end to another in a few widely spaced trips. While I enjoyed the research many people do not. One can not simply drop into your local travel agency and order up a five stop trip from Surabaya to Jakarta. Even when visiting major cities such as Bogor or Bandung there is a dearth of pamphlets and tourist maps available at local hotels.

During my visits in 2018 and 2019 I stayed in a variety of budget hotels that ranged from $15 to $25. One in Malang was a colonial masterpiece. At another in Bandung I did not want to leave my room with garden view. A few other hotels were endured until the first chance to escape. Even with research it was hard to know what you were getting.

Food was great. There are sights, temples, markets and gardens around every corner. I never took an Indonesian train trip that I did not enjoy. Java is well worth visiting again and again. It just takes a bit of research and touch of serendipity.

Expand full comment

Sounds amazing. Thank you for sharing this.

Expand full comment
author

Welcome :)

Expand full comment
Oct 31, 2020Liked by Stuart McDonald

Oh Java❤️ Folk either love it or hate it! You’ve made us recall memories of our first magical visit and also repeated hubby’s debate points on repeat returns! This is why we so enjoy Couchfish.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks Lindy!

Expand full comment

What a great read. Now I'm inspired to return to Java, having spent three months there back in, let's see, 1973. So glad to hear the people are still open and friendly. Thanks a bunch, Stuart, you've outdone yourself!

Expand full comment

I lived in Jakarta for nearly 30 years before retiring to Bali. It's a remarkable city which in many ways is the soul of Indonesia, with migrants from all over adding to the remarkable character - and the cuisine - of the city. The immediate hinterland is now tainted by traffic jams and some areas such as Pelabuhan Ratu have always been a bit grubby but areas such as Majalengka and the area around Borobudur are magical, not to mention distant pockets such as Meru Betiri. Life needs to be longer to have time for it all! Now in Bali, I miss the 'real' Indonesia.

Expand full comment