15 Comments
User's avatar
D D's avatar

Here here! Alas, too much common sense, my friend

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

It seems simple right?! I don’t get what is so hard here.

Expand full comment
Lorcan Lyons's avatar

I wonder if any country will go all the way upstream to visa conditions in response to over tourism, that is, you can come to our country but you must visit in such and such a way

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

I think Bhutan the closest example to that, but it is really just “pay us money.” There are though some interesting approaches, years ago I wrote a piece (can’t find it now as I just woke up!) suggesting one approach Indonesia could take to better disperse travellers and to lighten the load on Bali would be to remove the ability to get a visa extension there, instead saying you had to go to another island, say Lombok, which you could use once, then Flores, or Java or whatever.

At the time people suggested agents would just run passports around, but that’s no longer possible as you need to get fingerprinted, and it would work to at least encourage people to travel a bit further and see a more diverse range of stuff.

That’s but one approach--nome perfect, but it would be good to see more places at least try.

Expand full comment
John French's avatar

Great article. The worst is when you are at the beach and there are miles of empty sand and someone puts their towel down right next to you - uggh!!!

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

I know!!!!! There’s the whole goddam beach and yet?

Expand full comment
alistair's avatar

I too have been mystified by the idiots who all rush to the boarding gate when they announce boarding for rows 20 to 30 or whatever. This should make boarding much quicker and easier for everyone.

My solution would be to turn all the queue jumpers to a separate queue where all their hand luggage is weighted and measured and every bag 1 gram over the limit or 1 centimeter to big was moved to the hold and they should then be the last to board.

Things could be worse Stuart when the next day you get on a plane and find the idiot from the cafe is sat next to you for the next 6 hours

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

Oh yes! The number of times I’ve been sitting there waiting and thought “I bet that person is going to be sitting by me” and then ... you know the rest of the story!

Expand full comment
Hash Modha's avatar

Always great reading, Thank you.... Best from Thailand weather conditions upside down here!😂

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

Cheers!

Expand full comment
c1ue's avatar

I understand the sentiment, but it is equally valid to point out that tourism these days is much more about Veblen good consumption than it is about self enrichment/enlightenment/improvement.

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

Now you have me googling Veblen -- is that a typo?!

Expand full comment
c1ue's avatar

Thorstein Veblen was an economist - a Veblen good is something people buy/use because it shows they are wealthy, not because the good itself has any specific intrinsic value.

Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

Ahhh gotcha, learn something every day. And yes, I agree!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 23, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Stuart McDonald's avatar

Sorry, missed this. Yes I think religious pilgrims are a special case, but again they can be allotted to. Perhaps on big pilgrimage days, recreational trekkers are not permitted--I’d support something like that. In pecking order, I’d suggest pilgrims > domestic tourists > foreign tourists--in that order, and limit tickets accordingly.

Expand full comment